| QUOTE (buddy @ Nov 1 2007, 02:51 PM) |
| From recent article by Devvy Kidd quoting David Ray Griffin: http://www.newswithviews.com/Devvy/kidd319.htm ------------------------------------------------------------------ How can any of us forget the heart wrenching phone calls from passengers who perished that day? Phone calls to loved ones. The pain, anguish, fear and courage -- all conveyed via cell phones from these hijacked planes. Or were they? David Ray Griffin has authored several books on 911; a must read by Griffin is Debunking 9/11 Debunking: An Answer to Popular Mechanics and Other Defenders of the Official Conspiracy Theory. In an October 12, 2007, article Griffin drops a bomb shell: "The most famous of the reported calls from the flights supposedly came from Barbara Olson, the well-known commentator on CNN who was married to Ted Olson, who was then the US solicitor general. Olson reported that his wife had called him twice from American Airlines Flight 77, stating that hijackers with knives and boxcutters had taken over the plane. Besides providing evidence of hijackers, this call also provided the only evidence that Flight 77 was still aloft (it had disappeared from radar and there had been reports of an airliner crash nearby). Although Olson went back and forth on the question of whether his wife had used a cell phone or an onboard phone, he finally settled on the latter. "In the first edition, I challenged this claim on the basis of evidence from American Airlines that their Boeing 757 (which is what Flight 77 was) had no onboard phones. After publishing the book, however, I became worried, because of some new evidence, that the statement from American Airlines, made in 2004, had referred only to their 757s at that time - that their 757s in 2001 may well have had onboard phones. So I published a retraction, saying that the claim was uncertain. "That retraction, however, evoked new evidence, including a statement made by American Airlines in 2006 that their 757s in 2001 had had no onboard phones, so that anyone calling out from Flight 77 had needed to use a cell phone. Barbara Olson, therefore, could not have used a passenger-seat phone. That left open, of course, the possibility that Ted Olson was correct when he said that his wife had used her cell phone. "However, the evidence from the Moussaoui trial ruled out this possibility. In its report on AA 77, it listed one attempted call from Barbara Olson, which was "unconnected" and hence lasted "0 seconds." This was an astounding discovery. The FBI is part of the Department of Justice. And yet it had undercut the testimony of the DOJ's former solicitor general, saying in effect that the two calls that he reported had never happened. The implication is that unless Ted Olson had, like Deena Burnett, been duped, he had lied. Although this should have produced front-page headlines, it has thus far not been reported by any mainstream publication. The Revised and Updated Edition of "Debunking 9/11 Debunking" provides the documentation for these reports from American Airlines and the FBI, which pretty thoroughly undermine the idea that any of the reported calls were genuine: If the cell phone calls were faked, why should we believe that the reported calls from onboard phones were genuine?" Griffin has much more to say on this; click here. :o |
| QUOTE (Zaphod 36 @ Nov 9 2007, 12:26 PM) |
| When this phone call never happened, then Ted Olson was lying. There must be a reason for this lie. Was the reason just to confirm the existence of American 77 at this time(around 9:20)? |
| QUOTE (hotrob1017 @ Dec 7 2007, 11:11 PM) |
| Hang on a second, when was it established that Barbara Olson's phone call "never happened"? I realize there was some confusion over whether she used an on-board phone or a cell, but how does any of that prove that the call didn't happen? Griffin cites an FBI report in the Moussaoui trial which listed "one attempted call from Barbara Olson, which was "unconnected" and hence lasted "0 seconds." What Dr. Griffin neglects to mention is whether or not there were any other calls from Mrs. Olson. I still think we're a long way from conclusively proving that this phone call did not take place. |
| QUOTE |
| "The Kean Commission, perhaps aware of the swell of scepticism around it, addresses the question of this notorious call, introducing a new evasion. Apparently all calls from Flight 11 were all made to an unknown number! Their footnote states: The records available for the phone calls from American 77 do not allow for a determination of which of four connected calls to unknown number represent the two between Barbara and Ted Olson, although the FBI and DOJ (dept. of justice) believe that all four represent communications between Barbara Olson and her husband's office..." |
| QUOTE (fedzcametogetme @ Dec 8 2007, 05:18 AM) |
| lets say it did happen. then there's a problem based on the context of her alleged words. |
| QUOTE (HandsomeCoolDude @ Dec 23 2007, 03:50 PM) | ||
this is fine considering that if you're on a plane hijacked by terrorists, i don't think your words will be very coherent either |