
| QUOTE (Nemi the Nen @ Dec 27 2006, 04:40 PM) |
| 2) Eragon is a step off of plagerisim. Compare it to Star Wars episode 4. Empire is headed up by a man who was once prominate and respected. Orphan boy lives on a farm on the outskirts of said empire. A princess of the rebellion sends a vital object to an old man who was part of the same respected organization as the emperor's second in command. However, it comes into the boy's posession. The Boy meets up with the old man to learn the ways of his organization and starts to 'see' the princess calling for help and decides to rescue her. Boy eventually returns home, which has been burnt and his uncle killed. Old man and Boy meet a rouge who is good hearted despite apearances. The old man dies saving the boy and the boy goes on to bring the vital information/thing to the resistance/princess. ...I could go on, infact I practacally cut and pasted that from a website ( http://www.anti-shurtugal.com/starwars.htm ). Replace Brom with Obi Wan, Eragon with Luke, Murtagh with Han Solo, Arya with Leia and so forth and pop it into a faux medieval world. |
| QUOTE (Nemi the Nen @ Dec 26 2006, 10:40 PM) |
| 2) Eragon is a step off of plagerisim. Compare it to Star Wars episode 4. |
| QUOTE (The Furox @ Dec 28 2006, 03:49 AM) | ||
Though Lucas' story idea for Star Wars wasn't completely original either. :) He based it off the samurai films of Akira Kurosawa, including "The Hidden Fortress". He basically adapted the story from these Japanese samurai movies and made them into an outer space sci-fi adventure more closely aligned with western culture. Lucas even copied a cantina scene where someone gets their arm cut off with a sword. And Lucas derived the word "Jedi" from the Japanese "Jidai Geki" which refers to samurai movies. But then Kurosawa was said to borrow ideas for his samurai movies from American westerns and detective stories! So perhaps we should say that Eragon inherits from those instead. :D Check out this link for the Akira Kurosawa/Star Wars relationship. Ultimately, I think there are very few original story ideas. Every writer is influenced by what they've read and seen, and they just add some of their own inspiration to the mix. Sorry if I'm venturing too far off topic. :) I'll stop now. Oh, and nice dragon, DragonBooster500! :cookie: |